No, I surely hope we make the playoffs. My questions weren't rhetorical...

SteveM 2284 posts Joined: Sep 9, 2011

Posted 1:46 pm on Oct 22, 2024

Will the voters take ND over a 1 loss BYU or 1 loss Iowa State or
a 2 loss Tennessee or 2 loss Alabama or 2 loss Ohio State?

Right now, some say yes, others say no.

Replies 30

No, I surely hope we make the playoffs. My questions weren't rhetorical... SteveM 1:46pm · 10/22/24
- No calculator can account for all the variables a committee will consider. ndphysics 1:50pm · 10/22/24
  - Your questions aren't rhetorical, they dismiss 25+ years of history and data Turkish 2:46pm · 10/22/24
    - Which team above us has a weaker schedule let alone teamsNT WoodstockIrish 8:05am · 10/23/24
      - Penn St, Clemson, Iowa St, BYU Turkish 8:24am · 10/23/24
        
        All have played teams in the top 10, have 2-3 ranked opponents WoodstockIrish 10:10am · 10/23/24
        
        We're ranked behind them now because we lost to NIU and 3 of them are undefeated still Turkish 1:43pm · 10/23/24
        
        It's lovely how wrong you are. The teams I mentioned have beaten nobody.NT Turkish 1:38pm · 10/23/24
        
        Since Clemson was motor boated at home, they haven't played a single ranked team...in fact Chrisb 11:10am · 10/23/24
        
        They played #1, will play #19 and will play a top ten 10 in their conference WoodstockIrish 12:23pm · 10/23/24
        
        You're talking about what they WILL do, current ranking is about what you have done, we HAVE beaten Chrisb 1:20pm · 10/23/24
        
        Because my comment originally to the Turk guy was that several teaNT WoodstockIrish 10:27pm · 10/23/24
        Continue 2 replies
        
        Oh yeah, and.. Chrisb 1:25pm · 10/23/24
    - Your rational and fact-based arguments are not appreciated around here, pal Nigel Tufnel 5:05pm · 10/22/24
      - A 1-loss SEC or Big 10 team who then loses 2nd game in the conference championship WoodstockIrish 12:45pm · 10/23/24
        
        So what? It's a 12 team playoffNT Turkish 1:40pm · 10/23/24

View Full Conversation