Meh; there's a reason vegas disagrees with you...
As is common in college football, teams have substantial game-to-game variability in performance, particularly when the next man in is often a significant step down. Meanwhile, lesser opponents have strong incentives to gamble on identifying and exploiting particular weaknesses.
A bad performance doesn't necessarily mean a team isn't very good. There's a reason Vegas looks beyond the most recent result.
That's why I favor my "BCS-Lite" approach, which balances three fundamentally different ways of evaluating teams:
- Colley: Pure results — wins and losses against the schedule actually played.
- Sagarin: Performance-based predictive strength — how good the team actually is.
- AP/Coaches: Human judgment — contextual evaluation, including injuries and other factors the models might miss.
I take the geometric mean of the three, giving exceptional performance in any one category meaningful weight without letting weakness in another dominate:
((AP + Coaches)/2 × Colley × Sagarin)^(1/3)
Here are my current rankings (tentative, since the new AP poll is estimated):
Rank Team AP* Coach Colley Sagarin Score
1 Georgia 1 1 4 1 1.587
2 Utah 2 2 1 12 2.884
3 Notre Dame 3 3 7 2 3.476
4 Texas 8 8 3 4 4.579
5 UCLA 4 4 2 15 4.932
6 Alabama 7 7 6 3 5.013
7 Miami 5 6 5 5 5.161
8 Indiana 6 5 8 10 7.606
9 Tennessee 9 9 12 7 9.110
10 Oregon 13 14 14 6 10.428
11 Wake Forest 10 10 11 11 10.656
12 Texas Tech 11 11 10 16 12.074
13 Ohio State 17 17 15 8 12.683
14 BYU 12 12 13 17 13.842
15 Iowa 14 13 17 13 14.396
16 Ole Miss 16 16 21 14 16.755
17 LSU 24 23 24 9 17.186
18 Boise State 15 15 9 39 17.397
19 USC 21 19 18 21 19.626
20 Kentucky 18 18 16 30 20.520
21 Louisville 19 22 25 19 21.354
22 Florida 31 25 20 20 22.374
23 Arizona 22 20 28 24 24.166
24 Houston 20 21 23 36 25.700
25 Duke 23 24 33 29 28.227
Alabama comes out #6, not because Saturday's performance was particularly impressive, but because Sagarin still has them #3, Colley #6, and the Coaches poll #7. One ugly game shouldn't outweigh the entire season.