Re: Along those lines, I'm fine with the committee picking five at-large teams
Even better: Let the committee rank the conference champions (and champs only) to determine which 5 get automatic bids; let a BCS-Lite style poll rank everyone and the top teams get auto-bids until 10 total auto bids are granted, then let the committee fill the remaining slots with an explicit preference (but not a mandate) for conference championship game losers, excluded conference champions, and exclusion of additional teams from any conference with 4 or more automatic qualifiers.
THEN the committe ranks those 12 and those 12 only to seed them,
Last season this would have given:
Champs: JMU, Georgia, WMU, Duke, Indiana, TexTech, BoiseSt., Tulane, KennSt.
Presumably Georgia, Indiana, TexTech, Tulane, JMU
BCSLite (estimate): Indiana, OhSt., Georgia, Oregon, TT, ND, TAM, Bama, OleMiss, Miami, OK, Texas
Presumably: OhSt., Oregon, ND, TAM, Bama.
Then committee picks from: Duke, WMU, BoiseSt., KennSt., BYU
Presumably: BYU, Duke.
Who would have been left out? OK, Ole Miss and Miami in favor of ND, Duke, and BYU. BUT, they could have used their discretion to exclude Duke and include Miami instead, and likewise BYU for Ole Miss.