Super athlete, big arm
Coaches dream about these superb athletes who have big time arm strength, thinking they can mold them into the ultimate weapon QB.
In the past, this was far more feasible, since you could use a run-heavy offense from under center.
In this day and age, though, most teams use some form of the spread offense, and even the run-heavy spread offenses demand that a QB be able to make at least a WR1, WR2, and 3rd option read before taking off running.
Underwood can't do that, or at least he hasn't proven that he is capable of that.