These SOS ratings are all highly subjective.

D2 7923 posts Original UHND Member
Posted
0

I'm not saying ND had a tough schedule but it all depends on how the models are built.

I saw a model that had Tennessee below ND even though Tennessee played Texas, LSU, Alabama and Kentucky which are easily a tougher group that ND's toughest opponents. I've seen a model that had ND's SOS as high as 19 which is a joke considering we played our two toughest opponents at home (which matters), lost to BYU away and beat Wisconsin, arguably our 4th "best" opponent on a neutral field. Essentially ND was only "at risk" in maybe three games (Miami, SMU, BYU) .

The other stat to note is that there isn't a major statistical difference between the 10th toughest schedule and the 40th. A shift in wins here and there would have a major difference in the rankings. For example, Indiana had 3 OT games and 5 one-score wins. A close win that turns into a close loss would have a major impact on the SOS rankings.

All in all, SOS is pretty much a meaningless statistic. For example, Oregon and OSU were better teams before their most important player, their QB, was injured. But the SOS doesn't measure the before/after only that Oregon was 8-3 and OSU was 7-4 when both of those teams would have been better teams if their QBs hadn't been hurt.

Replies 11