macarthur...the most overrated general?
(no message)
Back to threaded view
Full conversation · 15 posts
-
-
-
Level 1
Admiral Nimitz got my uncle killed on Iwo Jima for no good reason
7,000 killed 26,000 wounded for a two mile island
-
Level 2
In retrospect it was a bad call. It wasn’t useful for naval or army staging.
It was used as an emergency landing runway for disabled B 29’s after bombing Japan. There were other options for that though.
-
Level 2
Was that really his call? Honest question. I don't know. [Edit: Seems the answer is yes.]
You make a good point, though. Did we really have to go after Iwo Jima? Why not leapfrog it. Wasn't the Japanese Navy pretty much destroyed by then?
Or, did we need it as a landing strip for bombers for the invasion of Japan? Seems like we could have found something closer, but I make that statement in ignorance.
[Edits: After posting the above, I googled this issue. Here is the wikipedia link discussing the strategic importance (or lack thereof): Wikipedia: Battle of Iwo Jima -- Strategic Importance
Also, it seems (again, per Wikipedia) that Nimitz did make this happen: Wikipedia: Planning for the Battle of Iwo Jima -- American Planning]
Evil preaches tolerance until it is dominant, then it tries to silence good.
-
-
Level 1
McClellan had the enemy’s battle plans & outnumbered Lee 2 to 1 at Antietam & still lost.
BaronVonZemo 64240 posts(no message)-
Level 2
Lee is among the best despite being on the losing side. yet, I know certain posters
will say we shouldn’t praise him.
-
-
-
Level 1
Officers are overrated. The enlisted is the backbone of the military...
Sure, there are great leaders, but their need is minimal as Senior NCOs really run it. Ask any former officer with integrity who really runs the show.
We're all born bald baby! -
-
Level 2
Yes and no...but I am starting to lean to saying that Bobby L 2 "e's" wasn't the best.
[Took me a minute to realize you were referring to Robert E. Lee.]
If you accept that the South should have fought the type of battle that it fought (open battle against the north), then he was a very good general.
The main complaint against Lee is that he didn't realize that he couldn't win a war against a superior foe that way, and therefore he should have adopted guerilla tactics.
But, let's face it, if he had adopted "guerilla" tactics, the New York Times would have called him a racist.
Evil preaches tolerance until it is dominant, then it tries to silence good.
-
End of conversation