Back to threaded view
Full conversation · 3 posts

Baseball HOF 2027 Ballot

Nigel Tufnel 8570 posts Original UHND Member
Posted

None of them would get a vote from me, except for Omar Vizquel, because I'm a Cleveland homer. It's his last year on the ballot and he's not going to make it. Buster Posey should get in eventually, but he's not a first ballot guy. A-Rod is an asshole and he got caught doing 'roids twice, ten years apart.

Chase Utley may make it this year, though he shouldn't

It's the Hall of Fame, not the Hall of Very Good.

Bobby Abreu
Jake Arrieta
Jay Bruce
Mark Buehrle
Asdrúbal Cabrera
Starlin Castro
Wade Davis
Brett Gardner
Cole Hamels
Félix Hernández
Torii Hunter
Jon Lester
Andrew Miller
Dustin Pedroia
Andy Pettitte
Buster Posey
Alex Rodríguez
Francisco Rodríguez
Jimmy Rollins
Pablo Sandoval
Ervin Santana
Kyle Seager
Joakim Soria
Chase Utley
Omar Vizquel
David Wright
Ryan Zimmerman

'I define fear as standing across from Joe Louis and knowing he wants to go home early.' - Max Baer
  • Level 1

    Some other metrics

    (Meant as a reply to Albany)

    Some other metrics, from baseball-reference.com.

    A great career and complete 2nd baseman. Belongs in the Hall of Very Good.

    Hall of Fame Statistics

    Black Ink: Batting - 11 (280th), Average HOFer ≈ 27

    Gray Ink:  Batting - 70 (475th), Average HOFer ≈ 144

    Hall of Fame Monitor:  Batting - 94 (203rd), Likely HOFer ≈ 100

    Hall of Fame Standards:  Batting - 32 (290th), Average HOFer ≈ 50

    JAW Second Base (20th):
        51.8 career WAR | 40.9 7yr-peak WAR | 46.4 JAWS | 5.6 WAR/162
      Average HOF 2B (out of 21):
        69.1 career WAR | 44.2 7yr-peak WAR | 56.6 JAWS | 5.1 WAR/162

    'I define fear as standing across from Joe Louis and knowing he wants to go home early.' - Max Baer
  • Level 1

    Dustin Pedroia....

    Dustin Pedroia’s Career Stats vs. Hall of Famers

    Pedroia’s career line is .299/.365/.439 with 1,805 hits, 140 HR, 725 RBI, 922 R, 138 SB, and a 51.8 career WAR — above the average Hall of Fame second baseman by key metrics favicon?url=www.baseball-reference.comBaseball-Reference.com+1.

    Career Totals (2006–2019) favicon?url=www.baseball-reference.comBaseball-Reference.com+1

    • Games: 1,512
    • At-bats: 6,031
    • Hits: 1,805
    • Doubles: 394
    • Triples: 15
    • Home runs: 140
    • RBIs: 725
    • Runs: 922
    • Stolen bases: 138
    • Batting average: .299
    • OBP: .365
    • SLG: .439
    • OPS: .804
    • WAR (Baseball Reference): 51.8
    • bWAR (FanGraphs): 53.3
    • Awards: 4× All-Star, 4× Gold Glove, 1× MVP (2008), 1× Silver Slugger, 2× World Series champion, 2007 ROY

    How He Compares to Hall of Famers favicon?url=www.mlb.comMLB

    • WAR: Pedroia’s 51.8 career WAR is higher than several Hall of Famers, including Lou Brock, Orlando Cepeda, Gil Hodges, Ralph Kiner, Chuck Klein, Dave Parker, Jim Rice, and Ted Simmons favicon?url=www.mlb.comMLB.
    • bWAR per 162 games: 5.6, above the average Hall of Fame second baseman (5.1) favicon?url=www.mlb.comMLB.
    • Position peers: In Jay Jaffe’s JAWS ranking, 18 second basemen are above Pedroia; all but five are Hall of Famers favicon?url=www.mlb.comMLB.
    • Peak production: From 2007–2017, only Jose Canó had a higher bWAR (60.5) favicon?url=www.mlb.comMLB.
    • Defensive value: 4× Gold Glove, 1× Defensive Player of the Year, plus strong defensive metrics for a second baseman favicon?url=www.baseball-reference.comBaseball-Reference.com.

    Context & Hall of Fame Standing favicon?url=www.mlb.comMLB+1

    • Pedroia is on the BBWAA ballot for multiple years, with 20.7% of the vote in 2026 — nearly double his 11.9% in 2025 favicon?url=www.mlb.comMLB.
    • His combination of ROTY + MVP is rare; several other ROY/MVP players have not made the Hall, but Pedroia’s sustained production and defensive honors strengthen his case favicon?url=eriklundegaard.comeriklundegaard.com.
    • While his counting numbers (hits, RBIs, runs) are below Hall of Fame averages, his value per game and defensive contributions place him in the upper tier of his position’s Hall of Fame peers favicon?url=www.mlb.comMLB+1.

    Bottom line: By WAR and per-game value, Pedroia’s career is competitive with or better than many Hall of Famers at his position, and his defensive accolades and two World Series titles add to his Hall of Fame case.

    Kind of reminds me of when Rocket Ismail played for Notre Dame
    Invincibility with no vulnerability
End of conversation