-
Level 1
In times gone by, Catholics ("Papists") suffered similar discrimination...right on this board we're
seeing the same attitude toward Muslims/Islamists...that's simply not right...you should know this. Enough with the "Muslims = Sharia Law = Terrorists" memes. Don't forget that hundreds of U.S. Afghan War Vets demonstrated in D.C. to get Special Visas for Muslims who risked their lives, and the lives of family members to save Non-Muslim Americans who tried to rid them of Taliban extremists.
_______________
AI Overview
Yes, local, colonial, and state legislatures in the U.S. have passed numerous laws and constitutional provisions targeting Roman Catholics throughout American history. [1, 2, 3]
Colonial Period and Early Laws
- Virginia (1642): Enacted a law prohibiting the entry and settlement of Roman Catholics. [1, 2]
- Massachusetts Bay Colony (1647): Passed a similar statute expelling or banning Jesuit/Catholic priests and settlers. [1]
- Maryland (1654 and 1692): Although Maryland was founded as a haven for Catholics, the Protestant majority repealed the 1649 Act of Toleration in 1654, outlawed Catholicism, and later established the Church of England in 1692 while forcing Catholics to pay heavy taxes and stripping them of voting, land-owning, and office-holding rights. [1, 2, 3]
- Colonial Charters: Most of the original thirteen colonies maintained laws barring Catholics from holding public office, voting, or practicing their faith openly. [1, 2]
19th and 20th Centuries
- Blaine Amendments (Late 19th Century): Prompted by a failed federal amendment, numerous states added provisions to their state constitutions—such as The Blaine Amendments & Anti-Catholicism—barring public funding for "sectarian" schools, which at the time specifically targeted Catholic parochial school systems. [1, 2]
Anti-Catholic School Bills (1922–1924):
- Oregon (1922): Passed a Ku Klux Klan-backed Compulsory Education Act to force all children into public schools and effectively close Catholic and private schools (later struck down by the U.S. Supreme Court in Pierce v. Society of Sisters).
- Washington (1924): Proposed a similar Klan-backed initiative (Initiative 49), which was defeated by voters. [1]
- State Convent Inspection Bills: Legislatures in states like Georgia and Alabama debated or passed laws aimed at investigating Catholic convents amid nativist and anti-Catholic political movements. [1]
__________________
-
Level 1
The bill itself doesn't seem to.
I read essentially 2 things into it:
1 - By putting a legal term on it, the state can amplify any charges of assault or more to perhaps "hate crime" category and make the punishments more severe if the alleged victim falls into this group.
2 - Providing official protected class status to this group.
I don't see any 1A infringements in the language. Although a conspiracy theorist might view it as a first step of sorts towards that end.
-
Level 2
Here are the 1st Amendment violations in the bill
This law would criminalize:
"hatred or severe disparagement towards Muslim persons or their culture"
"making mendacious, dehumanizing, demonizing, or stereotypical allegations about Muslims, or of Muslims as a collective group, especially but not exclusively, conspiracies about Muslims entry into politics, government, or other societal institutions, the myth of Muslim identity having a unique propensity for terrorism, and claims of a demographic threat posed by Muslims or of a Muslim takeover"
"expressing an outlook or worldview involving an unfounded dread and dislike of Muslims"
Just for starters.
-
-
Level 1
Note that it’s patterned after the British version - disastrous. While the SCOTUS
will likely strike it down at this point, imagine if the Democrats appoint a few SCOTUS judges.
The European/Canadian disaster is coming here next, and the Left invited it in.
BVZ -
Level 1
I would ordinarily say yes, but hate crimes exist in this country, so anything is possible.
Crime is crime, and speech is speech, and there cannot be specially protected groups in a country that claims to have free speech.
Dead-eye Pete with 20 pounds of swingin' meat. -
Level 1
Read the bill. Complete violation of 1st Amendment. But I'm sure someone will provide a link saying
that it's not.
-
Level 2
Look at the “data” the bill selectively cites already. “Studies show….”.
Selective citation of studies on one side, groomed studies, studies designed for preconceived outcomes, misinterpreted studies……all lies that become a challenge to refute when the population been dumbed down with a weak educational system that has atrophied their knowledge base and their critical thinking.
We saw it under COVID, and this “data” in the Soft Science arena is even easier to falsely pass off as fact.
Such “data” can be manufactured on almost any group that is desired.
In an environment like this, liars flourish.
BVZ-
Level 3
'tis juvenal. Give them bread and circuses...
Juvenal coined the phrase panem et circenses in Satire X (lines 77–81), criticizing Romans for abandoning civic responsibility in exchange for free grain and public entertainment.
Fast food and 'tv tainment' anyone?
Keep on rockin' in the free world
-
-
-
Level 1
Thanks for posting. Leftists despise free speech.
As Islamic violence increases, the demands for limits on speech related to Islam will increase. Leftists cannot tolerate uncomfortable truths, so they seek to shut people up.
I love "data" like this: "From 2014 to 2019, there were 10,015 anti-Muslim bias incidents, which included 1,164 anti-Muslim hate 21 crimes. This rise in Islamophobic sentiment is widely 22 acknowledged by the American people, as a 2019 study by Pew found that most American adults (82%) say that Muslims are 24 subject to at least some discrimination in the United States today.""Bias incidents" are nebulous by nature and unfalsifiable. Naturally, such woo-woo emanates from academia.
Final note: anyone who uses the terms "Islamophobia," "white supremacy," "transphobia," "Christian nationalism" is a moron. A low-grade moron. They are flawless moron indicators.