Cruelty lost in November midterms. Disgraceful.
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/18/opinion/trump-deportation-south-sudan.html
Excerpts:
Since taking office last year, the Trump administration has deported more than 500 immigrants to African countries with which they have no connection, often by bribing or coercing weak governments to take them.
Then the detainees mostly disappear.
I found five of them this month, held prisoner in a house in Juba, South Sudan. They were nearly starving, can’t regularly communicate with their families or anyone else and don’t have any path to get to their home countries or, in the case of some of them, to ever see their American citizen children again.
“I don’t know if I can tell you without being killed, but it’s horrible here,” said Enrique Arias Hierro, 48, a Cuban with a criminal record who until his deportation had lived in the United States since the age of 2. My interview with him was monitored by South Sudanese guards and a diplomat, but Arias Hierro pressed ahead with his complaints, saying, “I’ll take the consequences.”
“Sometimes there’s no food for two or three days,” he added. “Sometimes there’s no water for a month. Once for two and a half months, we had no drinking water,” and survived with nonpotable water.
The Supreme Court last year allowed deportations to South Sudan, over the dissents of liberal justices. However, the court has scheduled fast-track hearings for December on whether such deportations to third countries violate the Constitution and international protections against torture.
I hope the justices will take note of what has happened to those sent to South Sudan.
The five I met include two from Cuba, two from Myanmar and one who appears to suffer from mental health problems and could not tell me where he was from or anything about himself.
These deportees are held together in what the South Sudanese government calls a “safe house” behind a high wall and a locked gate, with multiple guards constantly present. The home itself is spacious, not at all like a prison, but they are not allowed to leave, have phones or contact anyone, and the deportees complained that electricity and toilets often don’t work. The biggest problem, they said, is a lack of food and water, leading one man to lose 30 pounds and another 50 pounds.
One of the men, José Manuel Rodríguez-Quiñones, from Cuba, said that he had once asked for clean water and as punishment was locked in his room.
“I was locked down for three days,” he said. “I didn’t eat for three days.” The others confirmed that.
Most of the time, each man is given three liters of water — less than a gallon — every two days, for drinking, bathing and toilet flushing, they said. (The National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine recommend that men drink three liters each day.)
One reason these deportees would be hard to send elsewhere is that at least four of the five have criminal records, including for attempted murder and armed robbery. (They completed their sentences in the United States before being deported, South Sudan says.) The Trump administration referred to them as “sickos” and “barbaric, violent criminal illegal aliens.”
There’s nothing wrong with deporting undocumented immigrants who commit crimes. That happens all the time, under Democrats as well as Republicans, and it is a problem when they can’t be deported to their home countries. But foisting them on impoverished African countries where they are not treated humanely seems to me a moral and practical failure.
Why were deportees originally from Cuba and Myanmar sent to South Sudan, a poverty-stricken, unstable country that has periodically teetered on the edge of civil war? The State Department website warns, “Do not travel to South Sudan for any reason.”
Remote, troubled countries appear to have been the attraction. “The point is to scare people,” an unnamed U.S. official said of third-country deportations, according to a report by Democrats on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee.
The idea appears to be to deter new immigration and to encourage undocumented residents to go home rather than risk being “disappeared” into a place like South Sudan.
While the Trump administration canceled AIDS programs that had been saving the lives of children with medicines costing less than 12 cents a day, it effectively paid African countries $32 million to accept people it wanted to deport, by the calculation of Democrats on that same committee.
Some countries received large payouts from the United States for taking third-country deportees — in at least one case, more than $1 million per deportee — but South Sudan hasn’t clearly received any benefit at all, except that America is once more granting visas to its citizens.
It’s not entirely clear why South Sudan doesn’t release the deportees or let them communicate regularly with their families and lawyers. (It says it does, but the lawyers dispute that.) My guess is that after the scare about all visas being canceled, it is afraid of doing anything that might offend President Trump.
So these deportees languish.
Human Rights Watch, in an excellent report on third-country deportations, describes the practice as “a U.S. policy that violates international human rights law and is designed to instrumentalize human suffering as a deterrent to migration.”