Where is the language in 2A and/or 14A that deals with concealed carry as a right?
(no message)
Back to threaded view
Full conversation · 17 posts
-
Level 1
Where is says “the right to keep and bear arms”. Conceal and carry is bearing an arm.
BaronVonZemo 64229 posts(no message) -
Level 1
By the way, if you want to be a strict textualist, I will totally meet you there. Do you feel lucky?
Something tells me you will run away, and post later about a living breathing constitution. You don't really want to be limited to the text on your own issues, do you. No, I know you don't. Progressives hate the Constitution, and work constantly to get away from the limiting text.
Evil preaches tolerance until it is dominant, then it tries to silence good.-
-
Level 3
So, are you a textualist or not? Are all government powers defined (and limited) by the text?
If so, we can have a long conversation about a lot of things the Federal government has done since the New Deal. You would lose on 90% of them. I'm willing to give up my 10%. Are you willing to give up your 90%?
Somehow, I suspect you are going to fight a limited fight on this one issue, and then reverse yourself later. Nice talkin' to ya.
Evil preaches tolerance until it is dominant, then it tries to silence good.-
-
Level 5
He ran away, as predicted.
(no message)Evil preaches tolerance until it is dominant, then it tries to silence good.
-
-
-
-
Level 2
Jim4twelve? Run like a bitch? Never.
(no message)"It’s always a wonder how you all are experts in everything." jimbasil 6/26/2022
-
-
Level 1
Where is the language in the 1st Amd about separation of church & state? The Internet? Pornography?
(no message)Evil preaches tolerance until it is dominant, then it tries to silence good. -
-
-
Level 3
Do you agree that abortion is not mentioned in the Constitution? More importantly...
Privacy is not in the Constitution, which was how SCOTUS got to abortion, and condoms in the first place. They created rights that "emanated" from the Constitution but were not mentioned in the text. By the time they got there, they were several steps away from the Constitutional text.
Same with gun control, which all hinges on the Commerce Clause. SCOTUS has finally been reigning that in during the past 25 years.
At least gun rights have a specific amendment.
SCOTUS has always generally frowned on restrictions that effectively take away the key aspects of the right...such that one could say they don't really have the right anymore. For example, the restrictions on gun owners in New York would never pass muster if they applied to free speech or the free practice of religion. Imagine having to get a permit to pray from local government.
Evil preaches tolerance until it is dominant, then it tries to silence good.-
Level 4
“The 2nd amendment is not a secondary right” - Clarence Thomas paraphrased.
BaronVonZemo 64229 posts(no message)
-
-
-
Level 4
They bring me right in with their conveyances. Just can't wait to read more. "What's yer favorite
jimbasil 55059 postscolor?
How dare you give women the choice - it's baby killing!"
Jack, he is a banker
and Jane, she is a clerk
-
-
-
End of conversation