Menu
Why did Gilman have to sit out a year, while guys like Justin Fields & Tate Martell were able to....
play immediately after they transferred from their respective schools? Both of them saw significant game action in 2018.
Don't get me wrong, I'm glad we have Gilman this season. If he played in 2017, he'd already be gone.
I'm just curious.
Replies to: Why did Gilman have to sit out a year, while guys like Justin Fields & Tate Martell were able to....
Thread Level: 2
The Fields case is a particularly egregious case of NCAA bullcrap
Hell his own sister didn’t have a problem with the University of Georgia.
Thread Level: 3
actually, it's OSU and Fields taking advantage of the race card and no one willing to call bullshit.
(no message)
Thread Level: 4
Why?
Does Georgia wind up with Fields, Frohm and Eason and we have Book and Jerkoff?
Thread Level: 5
Because the culture of racism that drove Fields away is strangely attractive to HS recruits?
That was sarcasm.
Thread Level: 5
Fields claimed he was racially attacked by the UGA baseball team. He said he felt unsafe. UGA cert
ainly isn't going to challenge that.
Thread Level: 5
Maybe because they don't have loony fans who call their QB 'jerkoff'?
(no message)
Thread Level: 5
I’ll
Save you the time
Clearly Georgia cheats
And they hate Catholics!!
Clearly
Thread Level: 4
NCAA is clearly prejudiced against Hawaiians
(no message)
Thread Level: 4
^^this^^
(no message)
Thread Level: 2
NCAA loves to screw Notre Dame pure and simple
(no message)
Thread Level: 3
Clearly
Everyone is out to get us....clearly!!!!
Thread Level: 4
Re: Clearly: I'm not paranoid, but everyone thinks I am!
(no message)
Thread Level: 4
I don’t care what you think. I do care that you may well be a nitwit.
(no message)
Thread Level: 5
Clearly
You don’t know what I think you are
Clearly
Thread Level: 2
The same reason ND had to vacate wins and North Carolina got off scot free
(no message)
Thread Level: 3
Can I get an Amen? Preach! SCOT FREE!!!!
(no message)
Thread Level: 3
Also Shea Patterson, he claimed that he did not know about the shenanigans going on at Ole Miss even
though his brother was on the Ole Miss staff taking part.
Thread Level: 3
This. Exactly this.
(no message)
Thread Level: 4
Clearly
Everyone, I mean everyone is out to get us!!! Preach!!
Thread Level: 5
Re: If you look at all the NCAA and Notre Dame interactions, you can draw no other conclusion
(no message)
Thread Level: 6
Clearly
That is why I said they are out to get us
Clearly
Thread Level: 7
Seems like irony, though. Can I ask two serious questions?
Setting aside the "they're out to get us" hyperbole, do you think the punishments for ND and UNC were fair in a comparative sense? And do you disagree that Gilman's denial of waiver is perplexing, given that he had an actual reason and the waivers seem to be given out liberally? I will just front my position: I can't square the punishment disparity between ND and UNC given the facts. And I've long said Gilman had as good an argument for waiver as any I've heard. But I also agree too many fans go to the "they are out to get us" well too easily and reflexively on too many items.
This message has been edited 2 time(s).
Thread Level: 5
Not really, just a high profile scape goat without conference cache’......capiche?
BYU would get the same treatment.
This message has been edited 2 time(s).