Poll: ND's football future
Please choose just one.
A. Independence forever
B. Full ACC membership
C. Full B10 membership
D. Full SEC membership
E. A new league, created from the fragments of other leagues.
F. ND de-emphasizes football.
Replies to: Poll: ND's football future
C
(no message)
E with stringent academic standards for all conference members. If not, then F.
(no message)
C
(no message)
C
(no message)
C
(no message)
Pray...
to Notre Dame...our Mother. As fast as things are changing though, she may be too busy to notice the landscape at the time she answers.
Seriously, mere mortals are making these decisions....and we know how that goes. Tough call, and for certain I would like to see independence forever. But we must consider and accept, if and when it becomes the case, that independence can be the end of ND football. No one knows what the next few months or a year will bring. I certainly do not like it. Maybe the college football golden goose is cooked.... I sure do not know but accept the remote possibility. Let's hope the N.D mortals making the decisions stumble upon a good outcome for ND
A. independence forever
BIG has NO Southern connection and that's where the best recruits come from. IF ND is forced to a conference it HAS to have Southern ties for them to compete.
Re: Poll: ND's football future
I think C makes the most sense for the entire sports program.
C
(no message)
C
(no message)
C
(no message)
C for now
Joining a conference doesn't have to mean your academics or reputation go south. No one dings Stanford for being in the same conference as Oregon. Or Vandy for being in a conference with...well a lot of lesser academic schools.
Having said that, the big 10 makes the most sense. Geographically, it fits. Academically, they aren't bad. ACC would have the edge there, but I don't see the ACC surviving. Maybe the big 10 will grab Duke, North Carolina, Virginia and Wake Forest to go with Oregon and Stanford. I don't see Clemson, FSU or Miami going North.
Eventually it may end up being de-emphasizing football, but until it reaches that point, big 10 makes sense. Even if we do de-emphasize football, there is still all the other sports to consider.
$
(no message)
First A, fallback C.
(no message)
A, E, C, B, D
(no message)
why does it appear to be the belief of so many that ND can't go toe-to-toe with the Alabama's and
OSU's of the world without sacrificing its mission?
You mean Rockne’s mission?
Imagine where the school would be without his mission.
ND can always just dissolve the football program and use the stadium for intramurals and picnics.
(no message)
And how will they fund the rest of the sports?
(no message)
The game is changing. Some schools likely won't require class attendance in the future.
(no message)
aren't you throwing shade on every football player still in high school?
(no message)
A...then E...
While I certainly enjoyed the football tradition at ND, it wasn't why I went there...I want ND to be revered as a university first, not unlike Georgetown.
Without football we would not have our favorable place as far as recognition now?
(no message)
other than for nostalgia, why would anyone want independence? It hasn't benefitted ND one bit since
the Holtz years. Schools in leagues have passed ND. League teams make more money. ND has to go undefeated to have any chance at the playoffs. The schedule has been watered down to the point the stadium is rarely at capacity. There is no benefit to being independent other than to stroke one's ego.
Silly nostalgia
Never knew that Holtz ushered in independence at ND.
What a dumb post.
He didn't usher it in, but it hasn't meant anything for ND since his time. It was great when ND had
it's own TV channel, but that means very little now. ND can hang onto its independence and be left behind begging to be let into the playoffs after playing a weak schedule that means very little to anyone but ND fans.
A
(no message)
Is what I expect to finally occur.
C is what I expect initially.
I expect E (eventually) once things get increasingly out of control.
(In a perfect world, I would want A.)
(no message)
A
And fuck every one of you who wants to abandon our identity, culture and tradition for money.
Seriously, eat shit, every one of you.
Fantasy Land
It is about survival, as I see it.
This is not a greed issue for me. I don’t care if ND makes more money or not. I like our current status, but believe we will be unable to go forward playing outside of some larger grouping.
Vote for what we WISH to happen, or what we EXPECT to happen?
(no message)
C.
(no message)