Notre Dame Jumps Two Spots in CFP Rankings But Still 9 Seed
(no message)
Link: Notre Dame Jumps Two Spots in CFP Rankings But Still 9 Seed
Back to threaded view
Full conversation · 19 posts
-
Level 1
The current rankings are silly.
PSU is #4? Texas is #3? UGA drops like a stone but Miami doesn't? 4 B10 teams in the top 5?
I want ND to roll through SC and watch A&M beat that soft Texas team. Grab a 6 seed and let's go!
Kind of reminds me of when Rocket Ismail played for Notre Dame
Invincibility with no vulnerability-
Level 2
We still have 3 games. And SC will prolly be a bear at home. All they have to play for.
Significant chance that we aren’t even in the playoffs. The rest is all BS at this point. -
Level 2
These rankings are as close to perfect as you're ever going to get...this committee is
doing a GREAT job so far.
The only question with PSU and Texas is should they be ahead of Tennessee.
Georgia dropped like a stone as I predicted because they took loss #2 and by 18 points. Miami lost their first game close and dropped to #9...they either play their way in or out of the playoffs in the ACC Championship.
These first two playoff rankings have laid the road in front of Notre Dame in Gold Bricks to an 8, 7, or maybe even 6 seed.
All we have to do is win out...we move up to 8 seed with Tennessee loss this week and then 7 seed the following week with an Indiana loss.
Then the dust from Conference championships settle to determine if we stay at 7 or move up to 6.
ie, if Tosu wins rematch we stay at 7 because Oregon drops to 5 seed and PSU holds at 6. If Oregon wins rematch PSU probably gets 5 seed, we slide up to 6 seed and Tosu gets either 7 or 8 seed depending who else does what.
Sit back, relax, enjoy, and just hope and pray we handle our business these next 3 games.
"Leave No Doubt." -Marcus Freeman-
Level 3
Spot on
(no message)'I define fear as standing across from Joe Louis and knowing he wants to go home early.' - Max Baer -
-
Level 3
Re: These rankings are as close to perfect as you're ever going to get...this committee is
Excellent analysis. The rankings, right now, do little more than promote controversy and fan interest in the playoffs. Lots of impactful games left on the table, and surely things will change.
ND just has to focus on every play in every game, and a spot seems likely.
-
-
Level 2
#6 should be easy. Georgia will take down Tennessee and OSU will dispatch Indiana.
I would love to "host" and SEC team in the snow!-
Level 3
Remember 1970 Curls. Multi loss SC team at home in the rain. We win that we have another Natty in
our case as we go on to beat Number 1 Texas in the Cotton Bowl.-
Level 4
I've been saying for a long time "if" we win out we're in and likely hosting...BUT
I'm still not convinced we'll win out.
At USC with all chips on the table for us and nothing to lose for them...concerns me to put it lightly.
"Leave No Doubt." -Marcus Freeman-
Level 5
We are on exactly the same page. Likely before your time, but check out the 1970 SC game above.
And even before my time, the 1964 SC game both in LA. Two nattys missing from the Irish trophy case.
I’ve seen and heard this story before. I like the Holtz approach. One thing at a time.
-
-
-
Level 3
Those two things will put us at the #7 seed...Oregon beating Tosu a second time in CCG gets us to
the 6 seed."Leave No Doubt." -Marcus Freeman-
Level 4
Ohio State, with 2 losses to Oregon, will be ahead of ND.
Penn State and the loser of the SEC title game will be ahead as well.Kind of reminds me of when Rocket Ismail played for Notre Dame
Invincibility with no vulnerability-
Level 5
Albany, I have come around on your take of only one ACC team getting in...
I expected them to bump SMU up after Miami loss...that they didn't and dropped Miami to 9th is telling...I now agree only the winner of their CCG gets in.
However, I have another concern...the Big 12! What do you think happens if BYU goes 12-0 then loses a close game to surging Colorado? Colorado would be in with the bye...do you think they would drop 12-1 BYU from Top 5 to all the way out of the playoffs?
"Leave No Doubt." -Marcus Freeman -
Level 5
Moral of the story: Don’t lose to NIU at home and have to pick up the pieces to even get in.
With a weak remaining schedule no less. If we get in, we will have the worst loss of any playoff team. -
Level 5
Nope, flat out wrong...this committee has shown their hand regarding 2 loss teams.
There is literally no 2 loss team more worthy of being over a 1 loss team than Bama (who has beaten Georgia and smoked LSU on the road) over Miami who just lost to an ok GA Tech team who ND smoked.
But what did they do...precedent is set.
Its true the committee will not "unduly punish" Tosu for losing their CCG, which is why as a 2 loss team they would still host a first round playoff game, they just wouldn't do it as a higher seed than ND.
The only SEC team who could lose in the CCG and even still have a chance to host would be Texas, as every other SEC team would be taking their 3rd loss, but while 2 loss Texas might host as #8 seed they wouldn't be ahead of ND. Again, they won't unduly punish a 3 loss team for losing CCG, which is why as a 3 loss team they would still be in the playoffs, just not hosting.
You are correct about Penn State though..we should just get used to seeing them seeded ahead of us, as unless they lose another game or struggle really badly vs Purdue and then we absolutely destroy USC, they will remain seeded ahead of us.
"Leave No Doubt." -Marcus Freeman-
Level 6
PSU with one loss has to stay ahead. We lost to a team that is mediocre in the MAC.
I just want to get there. Not at all a sure bet but the odds are decent.-
Level 7
I agree...I'm not complaining about PSU being ahead of us.
(no message)"Leave No Doubt." -Marcus Freeman
-
-
-
-
-
-
End of conversation