Watched the B-G game replay. What would be your QB depth chart for the Miami game?
If you had to decide today, what would be your depth chart for the Miami game?
I would go
1.Carr
2 Minchey
3 Angeli
Which I think sucks for Angeli who has been a strong backup transfers the last few years, but I think both Carr and Minchey are better over the full season.
With the expanded playoff, I’m even okay with losing one or both of those to get Carr the game experience to be ready for the December.
Replies to: Watched the B-G game replay. What would be your QB depth chart for the Miami game?
Please explain Minchey. He is the least perpared and lowest performer of all three.
This is like a Mike Singer post. Over optimistically weighing heavily on the UHND hopium: " more upside", "higher ceiling".
We have two very competent looking QBs. One with real game experience who also saved ND a spot in the National Championship. Another that has looked strong and comes with a strong but unproven in college pedigree, and we're still loving on the hopium train of a mediocre dual-threat???
Why? Seriously curious.
I liked his ability to throw on the run. And to operate outside the pocket.
(no message)
Because of the dual threat but I agree with you.
(no message)
Got it. It’s just not a threat if the chains don’t move consistently. Still waiting on his response.
(no message)
All three will stay through the 2025 Natty, then changes
(no message)
We will know the top 2 very soon.
It sounds like the staff is going to talk to each QB this week and let them know where they stand going into the summer.
Whoever is #3 after these talks will likely hit the portal, which opens this week. I can't imagine Angeli or Minchey sticking around as #3.
Carr has zero chance of being #3.
Question is, would Carr stay if he is #2?
(no message)
Yes under Angeli, no under Minchey.
(no message)
Maybe. Maybe not. Hope you are right if MF picks Angeli.
(no message)
Not sure there is a scenario where all 3 stay. Is Angeli getting his degree this spring?
That might be the one scenario that keeps him here if he hasn’t finished. I would think he is done academically on his undergraduate degree at this point.
Worst case is we lose 2 of them.
Don't see 3 staying in this goofball college sports environment...
(no message)
I bet it costs money to keep the starter and anyone they want on as a backup.
(no message)
Yep. And someone may be bidding up your backup(s)...
(no message)
I’m going with Penn State on this one.
(no message)
Ten guys will respond and there will be ten different answers---well, almost.
(no message)
I think this board is firmly behind Carr right now.
I think we're pretty split on who his competition this summer/fall should be.
I tend to agree.
(no message)
I'm firmly behind whoever the staff chooses to be the starter
They have a lot more experience picking QBs than I do.
This is the correct answer.
And if management makes bad decisions, the university (kind of funny to type that word in this context...the team ownership?) gets different management. Pretty simple.
In the meantime, though, I suppose boards like this which follow professional and semi-pro sports allow everyone to pretend to be management.
Why? He threw 4 picks in a high school playoff game. Aggies and Canes salivating!
(no message)
ND message boards don't decide. None of us have been at practice, film sessions, or meetings.
ND message boards form their already preconceived opinions from one practice game. But, fans being fans all over the country, in every sport, still have the obligation to form an opinion. It's the American way.
Correct. Neither does the Spring scrimmage. My money would still be on Carr though.
(no message)