Back to threaded view
Full conversation · 3 posts

Why I think Ash, not Freeman, is calling all the shots on defense.

MarkHarman 8075 posts Original UHND Member
Posted

One name: Al Golden. The defense was so dramatically different under him that if Freeman really preferred soft zone, Golden would have had to play it. But he didn't. This tells me Freeman gives his coordinators basically free reign, and is just signing off on their ideas.

Change my mind.

  • Level 1

    Not a chance that Freeman does not have any input to the game plan

    I'm sure for the most part that the coordinators make most of the play calls it is inconceivable that MF is not involved in the game planning. The head coach will make the game decisions like whether to punt or go for it on 4th downs, fakes, and things like clock management but once those decisions are made, it's up to the coordinators to call the actual plays with, for the most part, limited input from the head coach.

    • Level 2

      Your last sentence reflects what I was conveying

      But I don't see how Golden can play so aggressively while Ash plays so passively if the head coach is directing the philosophy. In any event...

      It appears to this outsider Freeman defers to what his coordinators want. I'm not saying he has no input, but with radically different philosophies between Golden and Ash, I don't see how Ash doesn't have a ton of influence on the game plan.

End of conversation