Back to threaded view
Full conversation · 4 posts

Would anyone here swap the Miami Result for the BYU one?

Turkish 1398 posts Joined:
Posted

Losing on the road against at Top-10 team by 1 the host team's conference admitting the game ended early and a blatant PI uncalled in the end zone? <Magic Wand> Penalty is called and CJ scrambles right and dives into the endzone for the win 31-28 with a walk off TD.

Beating the #1 team at home with a goal line stand stuffing their Heisman winner and a clearly incomplete pass by the Miami TE in endzone? <Magic Wand> ACC referees continue their season-long Miami bailout and the clearly dropped pass is called a TD. Cristobal has what Jimmy Johnson didn't (overtime) and the game goes into extra time. ND loses the toss and has to settle for a FG after a phantom Offensive PI call. Mensah has his "Heisman moment" throwing a TD while Boubacar Traore is being tackled from behind by the Miami blocker. No flag. Game. ND loses 37-34.

BYU beats UCF with no ND hangover but still loses to Utah. BIG12 front runner ranked 15th after 2 losses and no signature wins. Miami keeps #1 ranking with 80% of AP votes. Where does ND end up?

  • Level 1

    No way, we beat the #1 team in the nation with the whole world watching

    To top it off, the atmosphere and experience was really something you had to be there to fully appreciate.

    In short, no effing way would I trade.

  • Level 1

    No way

    We never want to lose, of course. However, when you lose to a classy opponent, as opposed to hated rival known as "Thug U," it's a much different kind of feeling.

    I said the same thing about the 1992 season. Someone once asked me if I would have been OK with trading the Stanford loss (ended up #9 that year) for the Penn State win (ended up unranked), and I said "absolutely not."

    First, and foremost, I have the utmost of respect for Bill Walsh. He has always been a man of class and integrity.

    Bill Walsh called an excellent game against us, and created several well-executed mismatches. That Stanford team was in near perfect sync, while we fell apart in the 2H.

    Yes, the loss was frustrating, and knocked us out of the National Championship picture, but if there were ever a loss that I simply tipped my hat to the coach, and moved on without too much pain, it was that one.

    Had we lost to that scumbag Paterno for a third year in a row, that would have been far more depressing.

    Before anyone says "come on, you didn't know about Paterno and Sandusky back in those days!" I will concede that point, but I did know about Todd Hodne and how Paterno moved Heaven and Earth to protect him.

End of conversation