Hypothetical: Manning enters the portal and CJ leaves. Would you want Manning for a year?
(no message)
(no message)
answer. Mendoza was a 2 star…
You need depth & experience at the quarterback position. If you can get better through the portal than what’s on your roster, DO IT!!
If MF’s first season taught us anything, it’s that you don’t want to be deficient at QB.
Period, end of story, full stop
Again.
He will be a high 1st round pick. He risks getting injured and his receivers will be middling. Zero reason to stay. The Clausen situation was very different. And, he also made a lot of money when drafted.
He would probably have benched him in favor of Tommy Rees if he had a multiple INT game.
He also wouldn't have used Clausen properly.
After all, Brian Kelly tried to turn Dayne Crist into a spread option runner, instead of letting him drop back and throw downfield, and it got Crist another blown out knee.
next year, do we go into the portal at all for a QB, or stick with what we have and risk a Michigan type year.
Don't want the Manning circus to come to South Bend.
Plus, he's only an average QB.
What about Kenny Minchey? Or the kid from Arizona or Utah? Get someone playing at a high level, not someone with a royal name who is up & down performance-wise.
just my 2 cents as always I could be wrong
I wish the guy the best someplace else, unless he’s lined up against us.
I respect your opinion, I just disagree with it.
I'd rather have a QB who has had coaching under Guidugli, and has played in Denbrock's offense. The team needs a strong armed guy who can make all of the throws with accuracy, precision, and timing, while having at least reasonable mobility.
We have two of them on the roster right now (Grubbs, Jarrard), and a freak of a player coming in for 2027 (Monds).
If Carr leaves early, then I suspect that the spring time will be a similar situation like we had in 1990, where Rick Mirer and Jake Kelchner were both given a fair chance to win the starting position. Even though Mirer had taken live snaps and Kelchner redshirted in 1989, Lou promised that both of them would start out evenly for the spring of 1990.
That was a situation where both of them had performed well during spring, and to be honest, I would have felt comfortable with either guy being the starter back then.
I feel the same way about Grubbs and Jarrard. This is a far superior situation compared to 2022, when the best QB on that team was a true freshman (Steve Angeli).
If we do look for a portal QB, I'm not too concerned about getting a top name, assuming that Monds makes a full recovery and is ready to go.
Jarrard and Monds both reclassified to come to ND early. Bringing in a transfer would send the wrong message, IMO.
He could very well take Manning to a whole new level.
When Manning isn't under any pressure, he throws a very good ball, with a classical overhand motion.
I've noticed that when he gets pressured, all too often, he forgets his classical overhand throwing motion, and makes a sidearm throw.
He's a senior right now, and has plenty of time to correct this, but hasn't. I'm a bit surprised that Sarkisian hasn't sat him down and had the "come to Jesus" talk with him regarding his mechanics and mindset.