Back to threaded view Full conversation · 3 posts

CJ Carr and the Heisman

nddad98 1642 posts Original UHND Member
Posted
As much as I would love to see such a talented and dedicated ND QB win the Heisamn Trophy, I just cannot see his chances being anything but a long shot...for one particular reason. CJ is not a run threat that changes a defense. Not that he can't run...all of us can run...he just is ot going to win games with consistent yardage on the ground...no Riley Leonard.

That said, he can and may prove to be an MVP on a national champion for one reason. He simply can process more things, make adjustments, and avoid errors and bad calls better than anyone else, while still throwing the ball with elite accuracy. But those things, although they are critical and can turn a loss into a win, are things the voters can't see and know...and therefore not valued. If they don't see it, they place no value on those talents.

But coaches and teammates know. We may not as fans, but this fan really values having CJ on the ND roster. Damned the awards, the NC Trophy is all that counts.
  • Level 1

    Hardly "The outstanding college football player" as if purports

    While it is certainly nice to win it, the winner isn't the "most outstanding college football player" unless you are a qb on a top 10 team in a power conference.
    75% of the last 25 are QBs at highly visible successful teams.

    It has become a qb award and the only time a qb doesn't win it is because the possible list is really mediocre.
    For example:
    2005: Bush topped Young, Leinart, Quinn and Robinson
    2009: Ingram topped Colt McCoy and Tebow:
    2015: Derrick Henry topped Watson, Mayfield and Reynolds
    2020: Smith topped Lawrence, Jones and Kyle Trask
    Side Notes:
    2006: Quinn had better #s than Troy Smith but OSU was 12-1 and ND was 10-3
    2014: Melvin Gordan average 7.5 yds a carry (on a 10-3 team) while Mariotta double his vote on a team that last the NC game

    In short, it has become a hype award when in many cases the sports media determines the winner before any games are played.
  • Level 1

    Excellent thoughts. He is not a stat machine but his football IQ is truly outstanding. If

    we win all our games, he has a chance. I know he cares about winning our games much more than individual glory.
End of conversation